Fifa Trials Innovative Technologies to Enhance Accuracy of Ball Out-of-Play and Offside Decisions
In a significant move aimed at reducing controversial refereeing errors, Fifa has begun testing cutting-edge technologies designed to determine whether the ball has gone out of play before a goal is scored, as well as improving offside rulings. The initiatives were trialed during three Intercontinental Cup matches held in Qatar earlier this month, marking a major step forward in the use of digital tools to assist officials in football.
The new "Out of Bounds" technology employs advanced tracking data, similar to that used in semi-automated offside detection systems, to provide precise information on whether the ball fully crossed the field’s boundary lines. This innovation was showcased in Qatar when Paris Saint-Germain’s Fabian Ruiz had a goal disallowed after video assistant referees (VAR) confirmed the ball had exited play—an instance demonstrating the potential benefits of the system in clarifying contentious moments.
Alongside this, Fifa has expanded the use of “Real-time 3D Recreation” technology, enabling quicker and clearer line-of-sight assessments for offside decisions. This technology produces two virtual camera feeds replicating the perspectives of both goalkeepers, which are available to VAR officials and television viewers to better understand offside calls. Developed in collaboration with Hawk-Eye Innovations, these technologies aim to bring objectivity and speed to crucial decisions that have sparked controversies in recent seasons.
The Premier League, which has seen several disputed incidents that could have been resolved with such tools, stands to benefit significantly if these technologies are adopted domestically. For example, two seasons ago, Arsenal voiced frustration when VAR ruled that Joe Willock had kept the ball in play before an Anthony Gordon goal for Newcastle, as the VAR team lacked the necessary camera angle to conclusively determine whether the ball had crossed the line. More recently, the season witnessed several “line of sight” offside controversies, such as the debated goal by Eberechi Eze where claims arose that Leandro Trossard blocked the goalkeeper’s view, complicating offside adjudications.
Further advancements include trials of immediate offside audio alerts to assistant referees, designed to reduce delayed offside flags on clear calls. These alerts, which first appeared at the Club World Cup in the summer, are part of Fifa’s ongoing efforts to enhance the safety and fairness of the game. For instance, Nottingham Forest striker Taiwo Awoniyi suffered a severe injury in May after play continued following a clear offside situation; faster offside notifications could potentially prevent similar incidents.
While the new technologies currently remain in offline testing phases, and their availability in domestic leagues is yet to be confirmed, their development reflects a broader commitment within football governance to harness technology for improving match officiating. Fans, players, and officials alike may soon witness quicker, more accurate decisions that could minimize contentious situations and improve the overall flow and fairness of football matches.
Fifa and Hawk-Eye Innovations continue to refine these systems, ensuring their reliability and utility before potential wider implementation in leagues such as the Premier League. If adopted, these technologies promise to transform how referees and video officials make critical calls, paving the way for a future where uncertainties over ball boundaries and offside positions become a rarity.
— End —
